The Unseen by Ania Ahlborn

Cover of The Unseen shows a house with windows lit at night with pink smoke billowing around it.Gallery Books
Published August 19, 2025
Reviewed by Sharon Mensing

The Unseen falls along the border of psychological thriller, horror, and science fiction…and it does justice to all of them. We have a mother, Isla, who has suffered many miscarriages and is (not) recovering from the most recent. Her husband, Luke, has had her committed in the past and is doing his best to support her in the present. There are five children, ranging from a five-year-old to two teenagers, all of whom have been traumatized by their mother’s mental illness. Into this mix comes a very strange boy whom Isla insists they must foster and, with his introduction, the family’s world becomes increasingly fraught and dangerous.

Continue readingThe Unseen by Ania Ahlborn”

In the Time of Five Pumpkins by Alexander McCall Smith

PantheCover shows five pumpkins lying in a sandy field with hills and a tree in the background.on
Published September 30, 2025
Reviewed by Meredith Frazier

For those familiar with the long-running series and those just being introduced to it, In the Time of Five Pumpkins is quintessential Alexander McCall Smith and his No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency novels. This latest novel in the series features all the beloved characters, from Precious Ramotswe and Grace Makutsi to Mma Potokwane and even Grace’s shoes. It also features McCall Smith’s trademark voice and gentle philosophizing about the human condition as Ramotswe and Makutsi take on the investigation of a married couple, representing both husband and wife who each suspect the other of infidelity. This is tricky, of course, but after much thought, Ramotswe decides there is no conflict of interest if she treads carefully, especially considering that there are no other detectives to whom she can refer the case.

Continue readingIn the Time of Five Pumpkins by Alexander McCall Smith”

Death at the Door by Olivia Blacke

Cover of Death at the Door shows a ghostly hand unlocking a door. Minotaur
Published October 14, 2025
Reviewed by Mary-Jane Oltarzewski

For a story about the ghost of a hard-drinking woman who died – maybe by suicide, maybe by murder – investigating a homicide committed on her old mortal turf, Olivia Blacke’s Death at the Door is a fun, breezy read. Actually, the ghost of Cordelia Graves is only half of the team investigating the killing; her partner in this endeavor is Ruby Young, a sweet-natured 20-year old who lives in the apartment that was vacated (physically, at least) when Cordelia died under questionable circumstances shortly before Ruby arrived in Boston in the wake of a bad breakup, looking for a job and place to live. The two amateur detectives, one mortal and one spectral, hit it off in Blacke’s earlier Ruby/Cordelia novel, when they joined forces to solve the murder of their neighbor from across the hall.

Continue readingDeath at the Door by Olivia Blacke”

The Gallery Assistant by Kate Belli

Atria Cover of The Gallery Assistant shows a woman in silhouette walking in a red-tinted room
Published October 14, 2025
Reviewed by Barbara Fister

Chloe Harlow has landed a job as an assistant at a New York art gallery, discovering that she has a talent for researching artworks even though she’s never before had a professional job and dropped out of college. But when the up-and-coming contemporary artist who recently signed with the gallery is killed, Chloe is caught in the middle of something she doesn’t understand. Though she was at a party at the artist’s studio shortly before the murder, she was drinking with abandon and has no memory of how the evening ended, or how she ended up at home in bed. When the police come to the gallery to ask about it, she tries to cover up the truth, but it has a way of coming out, and soon she wonders if she’s a suspect.

Continue readingThe Gallery Assistant by Kate Belli”

We Had a Hunch by Tom Ryan

Cover of We Had a Hunch shows the title and author's name illuminated by a flashlight against a black background. Grove Atlantic / Atlantic Crime
Published October 14, 2025
Reviewed by Mary-Jane Oltarzewski

Tom Ryan’s We Had a Hunch is structured like a TV series in which some episodes are solid, almost thrilling, and some are kind of beside the point, but overall, they make you want to keep watching. Like many of that kind of series, it relies on shifts in time to propel the plot. In the year 2000, Sam and Alice Van Dyne, the teenaged twin daughters of a smalltown police chief, become famous for helping their father solve crimes, and then notorious when their attempt to apprehend a serial killer referred to as The Janitor goes horribly wrong.

Continue readingWe Had a Hunch by Tom Ryan”

The Librarians by Sherry Thomas

Cover of The Librarians shows a smoking gun muzzle against a red backgroundBerkley
Published September 30, 2025
Reviewed by Barbara Fister

Hazel is the newest employee at a small neighborhood library branch of the public library in Austin, Texas. She joins Astrid, who speaks with a lilting Swedish accent, Jonathan who is a strapping young military veteran who loves working among the stacks, and Sophie, a supportive and effective supervisor who is reserved and keeps her distance. Hazel picks up the routines quickly and deftly deals with the creepy old guy who tests all the new employees with lewd insinuations. The group gets along well, and things are going smoothly until the night they launch a new program of evening games. The group that chooses to play a murder mystery particularly enjoy themselves, and the librarians consider the event a hit – until two of the participants are found murdered. Continue readingThe Librarians by Sherry Thomas”

Everyone a Stranger by Kevin O’Brien

Cover of Everyone a Stranger shows a woman standing by a railing with a image of a Seattle newspaper in the background with the headline "war declared" Kensington 
Published September 30, 2025
Reviewed by Barbara Fister

Virginia Abrams has a confession to make, though she’s not seeking absolution from the stern figure on the other side of the confessional. She has sought out Monsignor Mundy, a doppelganger for the real-life racist demagogue Father Coughlin, hoping to convince him to intercede on her behalf to the powerful Senator Ronald Callahan for financial support for her pregnancy. She’s determined to keep the child she’s carrying even though the father, the Senator’s son, raped her. It’s 1943 and the Monsignor is not sympathetic, nor apparently is the Senator. After her attempt to get a small amount of money to cover expenses for the child’s birth, a man arrives at the law office where she works to take her to a private doctor, though it turns out he’s taking her to a back-alley abortionist. She only escapes by slashing him with a scalpel.

Realizing the powerful senator will do anything to silence her, she flees to Seattle where a kindly woman on the train has given her a lead on an apartment. Soon she’s settled with an assumed name and a lucky position as a typist for a reclusive mystery writer. But violence is never far away, and soon she’s involved in a real murder mystery right outside her window. A woman who looks remarkably like her has died on a steep staircase beside their apartment complex, and Virginia can’t help but wonder if it was actually she who was supposed to die.

Continue readingEveryone a Stranger by Kevin O’Brien”

September in Review

Image shows antique French post card of a cat drinking from a teacup.How did it manage to become October already? Where I write, the temperatures are summery and tomatoes are still ripening on the vine, making it feel as if summer reading will never end. Here are some recent books we reviewed to give you some ideas for mysteries that might be fit for your To Be Read pile. Come back in October for more, as we review historical mysteries, a debut that mixes science fiction and crime, a thriller featuring an art gallery assistant, and more.

Mette Ivie Harrison, A Special Interest in Murder – “While there’s a solid mystery plot here, the real focus of the story is seeing the investigation through the eyes of an autistic woman who has plenty of thoughts about the prejudices she faces and the misconceptions those around her have.” Barbara Fister

Christina Baker Kline and Anne Burt, Please Don’t Lie – “There are some themes here to think about: privilege vs. hardship, the role of social media in creating unease and anxiety, the effects of isolation, and more. But any related deep thinking will have to wait until the book is finished, given the pace of the plot.” Sharon Mensing

Amie Schaumberg, Murder By the Book – “Emma Reilly is a literature professor at a small college who stumbles onto a murder that seems to have been staged to appeal directly to the way her brain works, combining Pre-Raphaelite art with literary references to create symbolism she’s trained to decipher.” Meredith Frazier

Joe R. Landsdale, The Hatchet Girls – “Although much has changed regarding Hap’s and Leonard’s circumstances, this 14th book, like the first one, is about people trying to keep up with a world that refuses to stop changing. Some people can learn and grow from these changing circumstances, but for some, their commitment to a cause can go from passionate idealism to fanatical zealotry, to unhinged criminality, in not much time at all.” Mary-Jane Oltarzewski

J. J. Viertel, The Glass Eel – “This is a splendid debut, with deeply realized characters and a vividly rendered setting in which the well-paced plot unspools with many a jolt and a surprise. Perhaps the most striking sections of the novel are those that take us underwater, to see the world from the perspective of a crab, a lobster, and an eel.” Barbara Fister

Mick Herron, Clown Town – “…another delicious and absorbing trip into the Slough House universe, with its back-biting power brokers and its hapless but endearing and ultimately honorable clowns, all rendered with vivid language and razor-sharp wit.” Barbara Fister

Walter Mosely, Gray Dawn – “the convoluted plot is less important than the people whom it pulls into Easy’s orbit: lovers, ex-lovers, relatives and neighbors heretofore known and unknown. There are people, and animals, who can be simultaneously affectionate, loyal, and brutally vicious. All of them are in mortal danger, and all are working hard to protect one another. Together, they illustrate the expansive dynamics of Easy’s life, and of the human condition as a whole.” Mary-Jane Oltarzewski

Claire Macintosh, Other People’s Houses – “Though the setting is established through a sprinkling of Welsh words and phrases (and Leo’s stumbling attempts to learn the language), the focus is on a community obsessed with materialism and appearances, as well as on the evolving relationship between the two protagonists… an entertaining puzzle in a traditional vein.” Barbara Fister

Zoë Rankin, The Vanishing Place – “That tension makes the book hard to put down, as does her world- and character-building. Set primarily in the bush in New Zealand, the novel gives the reader a sense of claustrophobia and isolation paired with love of place and strength of family.” Meredith Frazier

Elmore Leonard, Picket Line – “Elmore Leonard’s long-lost, recently rediscovered novella, is a tiny, valuable thing: not a gem, exactly, because Leonard’s words don’t sparkle; there’s never been anything gaudy or colorful about his prose. The most extraordinary thing about his work is how he achieved maximum impact with minimum language.” Mary-Jane Oltarzewski

 

Picket Line by Elmore Leonard

Cover of Picket Line is designed to look like a picket sign with stenciled letters on a wrinkled white background.Mariner
Published September 30, 2025
Reviewed by Mary-Jane Oltarzewski

Picket Line, Elmore Leonard’s long-lost, recently rediscovered novella, is a tiny, valuable thing: not a gem, exactly, because Leonard’s words don’t sparkle; there’s never been anything gaudy or colorful about his prose. The most extraordinary thing about his work is how he achieved maximum impact with minimum language. He didn’t so much describe people, as cut them loose and let them react to one another, so that the reader could figure out what they were up to. His output, primarily Westerns and crime fiction, appeared as novels, short stories, screenplays, and teleplays, all featuring propulsive plots and memorable characters. Leonard wrote Picket Line in 1970, repurposed some of the characters and part of the plot into a screenplay that became Mr. Majestyk, a fairly profitable 1974 action film, and in 2000, submitted the original to a digital media start-up that went belly-up before releasing the e-text. It remained unpublished and unseen until this year.

Continue readingPicket Line by Elmore Leonard”

The Vanishing Place by Zoë Rankin

Cover of The Vanishing Place shows a cabin with a lit window in a dark forest.Berkley
Published September 16, 2025
Reviewed by Meredith Frazier

While The Vanishing Place by Zoë Rankin does contain a murder, a police investigation, and many unknowns, this isn’t a traditional mystery. In great part, it’s a study of how what we’re told as children—and even as adults—can shape our world views, how our perspective can color our interpretations of events, and how even a minor shift in that perspective can affect—and shatter—everything we believe to be true. There’s no heavy-handed philosophizing here, but the storytelling and its results are a bit breathtaking and may literally have the reader gasping at the end.

Continue readingThe Vanishing Place by Zoë Rankin”